As former President Donald Trump prepared to address a rally in rural Butler, Pennsylvania, local law enforcement officers were stationed nearby with a crucial mission: to ensure his safety. However, a series of critical communication failures and lapses in planning nearly allowed a 20-year-old gunman to succeed in an assassination attempt.
Officer Greg Nicol, a SWAT team member stationed on the second floor of a nearby building, noticed a suspicious young man pointing a rangefinder at the stage where Trump was set to speak. The device, used by shooters to calculate distance, immediately raised alarm bells for Nicol, who instinctively knew something was wrong. However, despite his efforts to alert the command, the young man, later identified as Thomas Matthew Crooks, managed to evade detection and eventually reached a rooftop with an AR-15 style rifle.
The officers, Nicol and his colleagues, detailed a series of missteps that led to the near-tragic event. Nicol’s sighting of Crooks marked the beginning of a frantic but ultimately unsuccessful effort to apprehend the would-be assassin before he could act. The situation was exacerbated by poor communication between local law enforcement and the Secret Service, as well as a lack of clear instructions.
SWAT team commander Pat Young expressed frustration, stating that the incident could have been entirely avoided with better planning and coordination. Despite the presence of local and federal forces, including Secret Service counter snipers, Crooks managed to position himself in a way that allowed him to fire at Trump, narrowly missing the former president but injuring others.
In the aftermath, the Secret Service faced harsh criticism for their role in the security breakdown. Congressional hearings highlighted the failure, with officials placing blame on local law enforcement for not securing the American Glass Research building where Crooks had positioned himself. However, Young and Beaver County District Attorney Nate Bible defended their officers, pointing to the lack of communication and support from federal agents.
Newly released bodycam footage from the Butler Township Police Department further revealed frustrations among local officers, with one officer lamenting that he had warned the Secret Service days before the rally about the need for tighter security at the AGR site.
In response to the growing criticism, the Secret Service has since acknowledged the failure and vowed to revise their protective protocols to prevent such an incident from happening again.
